Permeable paving for SuDS

Under updated national planning rules, sustainable drainage systems will be required on most new developments. Concrete block permeable paving can fulfil a range of functions, writes Chris Hodson.

Sustainable drainage systems (SuDS) are a method of surface water management that mitigates flood risk, supports green infrastructure and reduces pressure on local sewage systems. As climate change results in wetter winters, drier summers and more extreme storms, they are an important measure for making towns and cities more resilient.

Essentially, SuDS reverse the long-term trend of paving over natural surfaces, which results in rainfall being channelled straight into urban drainage rather than absorbed into the ground where it falls. When a large amount of rain falls within a short period of time, drainage systems can become overwhelmed, resulting in surface water flooding.

In the new National Planning Policy Framework, released in August, the government made SuDS integral to new developments in England. It states that SuDS should be incorporated into proposals that could affect drainage on or around the development site, to control flow rates and reduce the volume of run-off. Where possible, these systems should provide multifunctional benefits, and improve water quality, biodiversity and amenity. SuDS are already a legal requirement on most developments in Scotland and Wales.

How do SuDS work?

SuDS mimic natural drainage in several ways. Water is allowed to soak into the ground or be conveyed slowly on the surface. Pollutants are filtered out, and controlling the flow allows sediments to settle out. To achieve this, they incorporate a range of “hard” and “soft” features tailored to the requirements and opportunities of each site.

A key SuDS concept is “source control”, where water is dealt with when and where it falls, through green roofs, rainwater harvesting and permeable surfaces. A steady flow of relatively clean water moves onward along a “management train”. This is a series of SuDS features that progressively clean and channel it to where it can be stored to provide benefits for people and wildlife, for example in open basins, wetlands and ponds.

Supporting nature

Features such as tree pits, geocellular systems and impermeable sub-bases can also be included to support street trees and green infrastructure, provide additional water storage, accommodate statutory services or meet other requirements. Materials can also be combined using methods such as the Stockholm system.

This mixes a load-bearing base of compacted crushed stone with additions including biochar, compost, soil or other materials to provide voids that encourage tree root growth.

Concrete block permeable paving

Pervious pavements are used as part of SuDS to provide a hard surface for pedestrians and vehicles, while still allowing rainwater to infiltrate down into the lower layers.

The term “pervious” encompasses two sub-categories: in “porous” surfaces, water infiltrates through pores across their area. In “permeable” surfaces, it infiltrates through joints between impermeable units.

Concrete block permeable paving is an example of the latter. The key difference to conventional block paving is that the joints between the blocks are enlarged, and filled by with angular grit rather than the usual block paving jointing sand.

Angular grit is also used as a laying course, typically supported by a coarse-graded aggregate sub-base with voids of approximately 30% by volume. This means that water can drain away between the blocks. The grit filters out pollutants, and the subgrade temporarily stores the water before releasing it slowly down the management train.

Types of permeable paving system

In most permeable pavements constructed to date, water is stored and released slowly using one of three systems: total infiltration, partial infiltration or no infiltration. It is important to determine the appropriate system for specific applications and conditions.

This will depend on infiltration rates, groundwater levels, the need to manage contaminants and pollution, and whether the water is intended to be used for landscaping or other purposes.

1. Total infiltration

These systems are used where all of the collected water can be discharged into the ground. Water infiltrates between the concrete blocks, passing through the constructed layers below and into the subgrade. None is discharged into the next stage of the management train or the sewer system, and there is no need for pipes and gulleys.

2. Partial infiltration

These systems are used where the existing subgrade is only capable of absorbing water slowly, or where interception is required. Perforated outlet pipes within the paving collect the excess water and drain it to another part of the management train or drainage system.

A flow-control device slows the discharge, so that water is temporarily stored within the pavement. Alternatives to pipes include fin-drains, proprietary drainage systems or geocomposite blankets placed below the pavement or vertically around the edges. During smaller rainfall events, water entering the pavement will typically infiltrate into the ground.

During more extreme events (1 in >10 years), excess water discharges to an outfall to either surface or sewer, at a maximum allowable rate agreed with the regulator. This ensures that water does not sit on the surface of the subgrade for long periods and the risk of soil softening is negligible.

3. No infiltration

These systems are used where infiltration rates are very low, such as on heavy clay, and designed on the basis that all water entering the pavement is discharged via outlet pipes. Even minor losses into the ground can be beneficial for reducing the volume leaving the system, so normally the system would not be tanked.

But a geomembrane can be included where the water is being stored for reuse, or where it must be prevented from entering the ground due to contamination or geotechnical risk.

Retrofitting permeable paving

Concrete block permeable paving can also help urban environments adapt to changing weather patterns as an overlay to the existing road construction. These installations comprise only the paving units and laying course, with a thin drainage medium below. This is a low-cost approach that preserves the embodied carbon of the existing road-base. As an overlay, permeable paving can collect, clean and store up to 20mm of rainfall, representing 95% of rainfall events.

In the absence of a permeable sub-base, the storage volume and level of water treatment is reduced, but this can be supplemented by discharge to a secondary SuDS component such as a rain garden. The paving overlay can also discharge to existing road gulleys below the pavement surface, for example when traditional stepped kerb streets are transformed into shared surfaces.

The structural design of the overlay should take account of the condition of the existing road surface. If it is in poor condition, the water could soak into cracks and reduce the strength of the underlying pavement. The existing surface should be sealed.

It is not necessary to provide a waterproof membrane between the new structure and existing, adjacent impermeable structures. The sub-base is dry most of the time, even during the majority of rainfall events, and stored water depths are normally too low to cause sideways pressure or water flow from the structure.

The permeable sub-base will also act as a drain for any water trapped in adjacent sub-base materials.
Permeable paving should not be retrofitted where the road geometry could cause concentrated surface-water flows, for example where there are significant cross falls or long falls that channel water into the gutter. It should also not take water from upstream areas that could be discharged as a concentrated flow in the gutter. In both cases, this could overload or bypass the permeable paving system.

Partial street replacement

An alternative approach is to partially replace an impermeable road surface with concrete block permeable paving along one or both sides, to avoid statutory services and demarcate on-street parking areas. Here, the existing road profile directs water from the impermeable carriageway and adjacent footways onto the permeable paving, which can accept twice its own area of runoff. 

To help designers meet the national standards for SuDS using concrete block permeable paving, MPA Precast has published The Permeable Paving Manual, co-authored by Chris Hodson, Bob Bray and Steve Wilson. This contains comprehensive guidance on all aspects, from overarching principles to detailed design, specification, construction and maintenance. Download it from mpaprecast.org/paving

Photos and diagrams Permeable Paving Manual, MPA Precast